Why is it that you do not tell Christians it is wrong to celebrate holidays such as Christmas, Easter, or especially Halloween?

Q: Why is it that you do not tell Christians it is wrong to celebrate holidays such as Christmas, Easter, or especially Halloween?

A: Your question is a very good one and something that many Christians have wondered about. You are right; many of the holidays that the Christian church embraces have origins and many practices that were connected to pagan worship festivals. We know that Christ had nothing to do with the Christmas tree, Santa Claus, the holly bush, and Christmas decorations. And since we are a ministry that is dedicated to teaching the truth, there must be a good reason why we do not teach against the practice of Christians setting aside special days of worship.

We receive many questions like this, especially around Christmas, Easter, and Halloween. Many people refer to these days as “holidays,” which originally was an abbreviation for the phrase “holy day.” Nowadays the term “holiday” means a day away from work or a time of recreation. Today people often say they are going on a holiday when they are taking a vacation, but originally a holiday was a day of the week that was set aside because people believed it had special religious significance.

In the case of Christmas, the Christian church dedicated it to the birth of Christ, Easter was to honor the resurrection of Jesus from the grave, and even Halloween is the derivation of “All Hallows Eve,” which came on the eve of the Roman Catholic’s special day commemorating their saints. Most Christian holy days have degraded over time and today we see that most are dominated by massive amounts of commercialization. The end result is the historical significance and any original Christian meaning is often lost among all the mass marketing and merchandizing.

Although we do not endorse any specific holidays, we do believe that each Christian has the liberty in Christ to determine what days, if any, he or she would like to set aside and “esteem to the Lord.” On the honoring of days, the Apostle Paul is clear in the book of Romans.

Romans 14:5 and 6
(5) One man considers one day more sacred than another; another man considers every day alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind.
(6) He who regards one day as special, does so to the Lord. He who eats meat, eats to the Lord, for he gives thanks to God; and he who abstains, does so to the Lord and gives thanks to God.

In His Word, God says that we can consider any day “as special,” but if we do we must do it for the right reason, which is to honor the Lord. If a person wants to set aside a time of the year to remember the birth of the Lord and to give thanks to God for his coming, then they have the liberty in Christ to do that, and further, if they choose to do it in December when the world celebrates Christmas, then they have the freedom and right to do that. It is wrong for Christians to celebrate any holiday if it is done for the wrong purpose, that is, with the wrong motives of the heart.

Regarding Christmas, despite what may have begun with good intentions, it is relatively well known that Christ was not born on December 25th, that there were not just three “wise men,” that the “wise men” were not present for Christ’s birth, nor was there a star shining over Christ’s birth site. We also know that many pagan religions had a major celebration on December 21, the winter solstice when the sun begins to grow longer in the sky. The Christian church seems to have chosen December 25 in an attempt to satisfy many pagan converts who were used to revelry and celebration at that time of year. The church did not really know the actual date of Jesus’ birth, but they believed he was born in the fall or early winter. Various scholars have only recently concluded that he was born in the early Fall (we believe it is actually September 11, 3 BC).

Similarly, Easter Sunday has significance for Christians as the day in which we honor the resurrection of Christ from the grave, and was a time of fertility celebration for pagans. In light of Romans 14, many Christians set this day of the year aside, even referring to it as Resurrection Sunday. For them this is not about any pagan fertility rites, bunnies, eggs, or chocolate candies.

God tells us that there is nothing inherently wrong with setting aside special days of worship. Even the Israelites, at God’s direction, celebrated a feast at the time of harvest, which was actually called the Feast of Harvest. It was also called the Feast of Ingathering when they all celebrated the gathering of the crops from the fields. It was a time set aside to thank God for His wonderful provision.

Exodus 23:16
“Celebrate the Feast of Harvest with the firstfruits of the crops you sow in your field. “Celebrate the Feast of Ingathering at the end of the year, when you gather in your crops from the field.

In the case of Halloween some Christians have chosen to educate their children about its evil aspects, and substitute “harvest parties” or “Fall Festivals” so their children have an alternative event to attend.

There are many things in our society that are based in pagan religious practices. Even the names of the days of our week have come about because of pagan idol worship. Consider the following origins for the days of the week:

Sunday: “sone day” meaning “day of the sun,” after sun worship.
Monday: “day of the moon,” honoring moon worship.
Tuesday: “Tiu’s day,” after the Germanic god of war.
Wednesday: “Woden’s day,” honoring Woden, the chief Anglo-Saxon god.
Thursday: “Thors day,” honoring the Norse god of thunder.
Friday: “Freya’s day,” honoring the Teutonic goddess of love, beauty and fecundity.
Saturday: “Saturns day,” in honor of Saturn the god who ruled the universe until dethroned by Zeus.

In spite of all the clear pagan meanings behind the names of the days of the week, Christians are not advocating that we change their names, or even stop referring to them as we do. Should a Christian not eat in a Chinese restaurant because they have pagan symbols as decorations? Or should we stop buying products produced by Buddhists? We recognize that the entire world has been influenced greatly because of paganism. God tells us that the whole world is under the control of the “evil one” (1 John 5:19). It is mature Christians who realize that, in spite of the world, they can conduct themselves in such a way that they always bring glory and honor to God.

The celebration of holidays is very analogous to the problem that first-century Christians had concerning meat offered to idols. In the first century a portion of the meat sold in the markets had been slaughtered and sacrificed to idols. God could have told the Christians to expend the effort necessary to avoid this meat on the basis that it was “polluted.” But God did not do that.

In essence, God has told us, “Don’t worry about it.” He said we were free, even free to eat meat offered to idols provided that it is not an offense to our conscience or that it did not cause a weaker (less mature) brother to stumble. He said that food has no significance in bringing us closer to God and we were no worse off or better by eating it, because the idol is nothing.

1 Corinthians 8:4
So then, about eating food sacrificed to idols: We know that an idol is nothing at all in the world and that there is no God but one.

1 Corinthians 8:7b and 8
(7b) Some people are still so accustomed to idols that when they eat such food they think of it as having been sacrificed to an idol, and since their conscience is weak, it is defiled.
(8) But food does not bring us near to God; we are no worse if we do not eat, and no better if we do.

If it is okay to eat meat that has even been offered to an idol, then doesn’t it make sense that a Christian can decide to set aside a day of the week to honor the birth or resurrection of their Lord? We do not endorse that Christians participate in any pagan rituals or practices that would dishonor God. We believe God is clear, that if they desire to, each Christian has the freedom in Christ to set aside as holy any day they like. This includes a day to celebrate Christ’s birth, or his resurrection.

Was this article a blessing to you? Comment below to let us know what you liked about it and what topics you'd be interested to see going forward! Also, please consider donating – even $1 helps! – to support the creation of more content like this in the future!

10 comments

  1. Thanks for the info. This came at a very good time because I have also received some questions on the issue that I didn’t answered as good and as clear as you did. Every day is a good day to worship and to celebrate God and our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. To me the date is a reminder of what happened. I know that in the old times dates were carefully chosen and I am very thankful to have had the opportunity to know the difference from Truth and/or Tradition; I believe that it is also important to explain these things to our children. Enjoy this season that reminds us that a Savior was born who changed our world and ourselves in such a great way.

  2. You are using Romans 14:5-6 out of context. There was a discussion in the church of Rome when Paul wrote this as to which of the feasts(God’s Holy Convocations) was the most important. This is what Paul was talking about in these verses not “making up” our own “holidays”.

    1. We don’t believe we are taking Romans 14:5-6 out of context. Paul was writing to the Romans! Gentiles, not Israelites who ever took part of God’s Holy Convocations, as you assert.

    2. I agree with you, Steve

  3. A very balanced and practical analysis of the subject. We, Christians sometimes waste time on foolish arguments (“9But avoid foolish controversies, genealogies, arguments, and quarrels about the Law, because these things are pointless and worthless.” (Titus 3) ) maybe even as a deliberate distraction from doing good deeds and spreading the Gospel.
    We instead need to determine in our minds the way in which we should work out our salvation based on diligent study of the Word and prayer.
    Personally, I aim to celebrate Christmas in truth, seeing the day as an evangelistic opportunity – what other day/celebration of the world actually has His name attached to it? Rather than spend energy in rejecting it, i prefer to shed light on it. Also, if I set a standard of rejecting Christmas because of pagan origins or associations, I would have to extend that standard consistently to all aspects of my life for example to rejecting the names of days (as you indicated), wearing my wedding ring, celebrating birthdays (all of which are also based on pagan practices) and even to not using Apple computers (with a bitten apple logo)……yes, setting this standard can result in the ridiculous consumption of energy in avoidance. This energy can instead be spent in reaching people for the Kingdom.

  4. This I know, God gives instruction on the sacred assemblies He wants us to observe. He even stated that they are His Festivals. He also tells us not to honor or worship Him the way the other nations worship their god’s . He is very clear about what He accepts and what He does not. In Christ there is one Family , one Father, one Teacher, savior, redeemer- Jesus. If you had a natural born child and then you adopted one from another country who practiced idol worship, would you allow that child to continue in error or would you just require that they follow a few of your family’s rules and customs? Having been adopted into the Family of God I have a hard time believing my Heavenly Father would required less of me than my Israelite & Jewish Family members. In Chris we are all the same and The Father does not have favorites. Our God should always be praised, honored and worshipped according to His instruction in a manner according to His will and desire.

    1. Thanks Karen, but you have to remember that the Festivals and holy days you are referring to are under the Old Covenant. That covenant was done away with when it was replaced by the New Covenant, under which we are to esteem all days as holy and celebrate and worship as we decide. We are no longer bound by the law in the sense we must or can only worship on particular days of the year.

  5. Romans 14 we live…we live…we die…we die.” A beautiful figure of speech, epadiplosis, which is the name of the figure of speech that occurs when the figure epanadiplosis occurs in successive phrases or sentences (Bullinger, Figures). “or a turning upon again” I love Romans 14 because it makes all this stuff so simple. Weather a man eats or doesn’t eat or rests on certain days or not, “i personally believe” the same could apply to all these myths, fables, and traditions, Jesus cares about one thing that “So then, whether we live or die, we are the Lord’s” So weather we are alive “we are the Lords” weather we die” we are the Lords, same for traditions. Just saying, I’m just attempting to study the bible, but Read Romans 14 and search it out a bit. Makes sense to me. “looks to me that God has our backs “no matter what way we turn” we are all the Lords, and in Romans, he gets the point across to quit bickering bout stuff and just let the gentiles and jews accept that Jesus is Lord and no one or nothing else is Lord.

  6. Most all of these`s comments are good , my question is God never done away with the Ten commandments , so when we parents or anyone tell small kids there is a Santa Clause and he goes around the world in one night going down chimney and leaving presents is a LIE . Telling kids lies about the easter bunny , telling kids lies about the tooth fairy , ETC. My Bible says God hates a liar , I agree we have freedom under the New Covenant but why would Christians want to take part in holidays that originate from pagan worship of things that are considered evil are from evil ? I would love to see halloween outlawed in America , Christmas is as halloween the two most money makers of the holidays .

  7. Ok so is putting up a Christmas tree some sort of pagan idolatry? I feel fine about the celebration of Jesus birth in December but is putting up a tree and giving/receiving gifts unbiblical in some way?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.