Tithing vs. Giving

FAQ: Most churches I have been to teach rather emphatically that Christians should “tithe,” that is, give 10% of their income to their church. I have even heard some ministers say that if you don’t tithe, God will not bless you. Must you give a tenth (10%) to the church? What does the Bible say about financial giving?

“What does the Bible say?” is always the “bottom line” in life, but that vital question needs a qualifier: “To whom?” The Bible, the Word of God, most certainly does speak about financial giving, and a good case can be made that it is one of the five most basic activities for a Christian, the others being prayer, Bible reading and study, fellowship with other Christians, and telling others the Good News about Jesus Christ.

The question must be: “What does the Bible say to Christians about financial giving?” Why? Because what God says to Christians about financial giving is different than what He said to the Jews of the Old Testament about it. The sad news is that today very few Christians understand the difference, and, as a result, many are unnecessarily living under emotional and financial stress. For a more detailed exposition of this subject than we can set forth in this FAQ, I recommend our audio teaching Financial Stewardship: God’s Heart Concerning Money and Possessions by Dan Gallagher as well as a book titled The Tithing Dilemma, by Ernest L. Martin.

And, as is so often the case in examining a biblical issue, that takes us to the subject of the administrations in Scripture. Unless we understand what parts of God’s Word are written to Jews, what parts are written to Gentiles, and what parts are written to Christians, we can neither understand nor apply its truths in our daily lives.

We are currently living in what the Bible calls the Administration of the Sacred Secret (Eph. 3:9), which began on the Day of Pentecost (Acts 2:1ff) and will conclude with the Rapture of the Church (all living and dead Christians meeting the Lord in the air—1 Thess. 4:13-18). The primary curriculum for Christians (i.e., people born again of God’s incorruptible seed) is found in the Church Epistles: Romans, 1 & 2 Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, and 1 & 2 Thessalonians. It is there that we must look to find God’s specific directions for us today, and the issue of financial giving is given two chapters worth of ink in 2 Corinthians 8 & 9.

There are also some pertinent verses in other Epistles, and the message of Scripture to Christians is that because of the finished work of Jesus Christ, we do not live under the Mosaic Law, during which tithing was instituted and commanded as part of the Law. Therefore, tithing as a commandment of God has no relevance to believers today.

At this point, it is important to distinguish between tithing and giving. Although tithing per se is not relevant to Christians, giving most certainly is. As a member in particular of the Body of Christ, each Christian is to determine in his own heart how much he gives and where he allocates his resources among his brothers and sisters in Christ (2 Cor. 9:7). The Epistles metaphor by which material giving is strongly encouraged is that of sowing and reaping—the more you sow, the more you reap (2 Cor. 9:6). “Tithing” is never mentioned.

Under the Law, Jews were to give out of their produce, that is, what the Lord had provided for them. Just like the Word says, “We love God because He first loved us,” so we give because God has given to us. When we understand what God has done for us in Christ, and that the material blessings we have come from Him, and that He promises to bless us back for what we give, giving cheerfully is a joy.

Even in the Old Testament, believers understood that when they gave to God, they were opening a door, if you will, for Him to bless them in return. This is, of course, still true, but the idea has been distorted by some Christians who teach that one must give to God before God can bless him. Thus, too many Christians are giving in order to get. No, God always gives first.

Also, He does not specify just how He will bless us. If we sow, we will reap accordingly, but it may not be money for money, etc. Some Christians have become disillusioned about giving because when they gave money to their church, etc., they did not receive money back. They may have even failed to notice the blessing that God did give them. When we give in response to a blessing, and not so that we will get blessed, we can be cheerful and contented givers.

Making known the truth about this subject is critical, because the vast majority of Christians are told, and thus believes, that it is God’s will for them to “tithe,” which means to give one-tenth of what they earn. Although they may be well intentioned,  many of the more “fundamental” Christian groups are adamant about this, and accompany this exhortation with a warning that failure to tithe will result in consequences of various kinds, usually having to do with a lack of prosperity. Often times, church leaders using the lever of people’s sincere desire to do what God says is right to squeeze money out of them. Such leaders proclaim that what God says is right is that you give at least ten percent of your income—to their organization. As a result of such pressure, financial giving has, for too many Christians, become a joyless, mechanical act of “bribing” God to avoid the consequences of not giving, and an attempt to earn His favor (something they already have!).

For many other Christians who once gave cheerfully, financial giving is no longer an act at all. They have stopped doing it altogether, either because they got sick and tired of the pressure being applied to them, or they really could not afford to tithe, or they saw the money they gave misused and feel that they were cheated when they did give.Neither of these attitudes—giving joylessly or not giving at all—is biblically right, neither is the will of God, and both are therefore detrimental to a believer.

In our economically driven world of today, having the right attitude about money and material things is a huge asset in life. Knowing and practicing what God’s Word says about financial giving will enable you to experience the joy of giving, and it will enable others in the Body of Christ to experience the joy of receiving and therefore having their needs met, so that together we can reach out with the Good News of God to a dying world.

A study of the Old Testament will show that tithing was instituted as part of the Mosaic Law to Israel. Some Christians point to Genesis 14 and/or 28 in a misguided attempt to prove that tithing was instituted prior to the Mosaic Law and is therefore relevant to Christians today. Their rationale is that because Abram gave ten percent of the spoils of war to Melchisedek, and because Jacob chose ten percent as the amount to give to God for watching over him on his journey, this is the prescribed amount God would have all people give. This is not sound biblical scholarship.

The Genesis 14 record takes place approximately 2000 years after Adam and Eve, and during all those years there is no biblical reference to tithing. Nor is there any record that Abram ever tithed as a result of some biblical law that told him to do so, and he certainly was “making money.” When he did give one tenth, it was not of the increase of his flocks and herds, which was the tithe prescribed by the Law, but rather of the spoils of war that he had gained by defeating the army from Mesopotamia.

In Genesis 28, Jacob told God that if He would keep him safe on his journey, keep him clothed and fed, and bring him home safely, he would give God a tenth of what he had. That was certainly not the Mosaic tithe, which was commanded whether or not those things happened. Both Jacob and Abram gave in response to a blessing.

Even in regard to Israel, for whom the tithe was specifically instituted, nothing was said about it until the beginning of the second year of their exodus. Prior to that, in Exodus 25, for the building of the Tabernacle, Moses instructed the Israelites to give “as their heart prompted them.”

You often hear proponents of the tithe say that surely Christians would do no less than what Jews did in the Old Testament, as if every Israelite gave ten percent of his income. A detailed study of the tithe is beyond the scope of this FAQ, but suffice it to say that the idea that each Israelite gave ten percent of his income (and therefore each Christian should do likewise) is far from the truth.

For example, an Israelite who had fewer than ten cattle born to him in a year did not have to tithe on them because the requirement stated that only the tenth animal that passed under the rod was to be tithed (Lev. 27:32). A farmer who had only eight cows born was therefore exempt from the tithe.

The tithe was basically on animal and agricultural products, and was paid in kind (i.e., the product itself). If one did not wish to pay his tithe in agricultural products, and decided to give money as a substitute, he was penalized and had to add a fifth part of its estimated value to the amount he paid (Lev. 27:31). Such a law was obviously not intended to encourage payment of the tithe in money.

The main purpose of the tithe was to support the Levitical priesthood. The Levites were responsible to minister to the people, and were prohibited from owning land, which obviously limited the ways in which they could earn income. God’s plan was that their support came from those to whom they ministered, much like the direction of Scripture for the Church today (1 Cor. 9:1 and following; Gal. 6:6 and following, etc.). The tithe also provided welfare for widows, orphans, etc.

One reason why there was no command to tithe until the Mosaic Law was that until then there was no Tabernacle (Tent of Meeting) and no Temple, no regular sacrifices commanded (the daily sacrifices alone commanded by the Law required more than 700 animals a year), and no class of Levitical priests to support. None of these would be relevant to a Christian today, even if they did exist.

Should a Christian today tithe? One is free to give 10% if he chooses, but we are not commanded to give any particular percentage or amount. Sad to say that many Christians, once misled and often emotionally coerced into tithing, stopped giving altogether when they learned the tithe is not required. 2 Corinthians 9:6 and 7 make it clear that the more generously we “sow” with the right attitude, the more abundantly we will reap.

For some believers who do not earn much, giving generously may not mean a large amount. For others, it may mean millions of dollars, and far more than 10%. Each Christian’s situation is different, and that is why God does not prescribe specific amounts that we should give, but allows us to make our own decisions. Remember, we are “fellow laborers” with Him, and He loves to work with us in determining how much and to whom we should give, and He loves to bless us with more so that we can give more. That kind of giving makes for an exciting element of the Christian life.

You may say, “Well, what about Malachi 3:6-10? That says people who do not tithe are ‘robbing God.’” Those verses have been used innumerable times to prod Christians into giving, but wait a moment—to whom is Malachi written? Well, in verse 9 of chapter 3 it says “the whole nation” is under a curse. What nation? The book of Malachi is specifically addressed to the nation of Israel, and more specifically to the priests (see 1:6,10-13; 2:1,7 and 8) who were badly mistreating God’s people. To use verses from Malachi as if they are talking to Christians is at best poor scholarship and at worst dishonest.

So what should Christians do about financial giving? 2 Corinthians 8 and 9 is the first place to go to find the answer to that question, and the heart of the message there is expressed in 9:7: “Each man should give what he has decided in his heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.” If, for you, that’s ten percent, great.

Beyond that, Scripture directs us to give to those who are genuinely ministering to our spiritual needs. When we do, we are making a sound investment in (that is, sowing into) a work that is bearing good spiritual fruit. Although there is no way we can help everyone who asks us, we are also encouraged to give to those in need, and we can seek the Lord for wisdom in doing so.

For a Christian, giving from the heart is all about knowing that we have a great, big, wonderful God, and also understanding who we are in Christ. Speaking of the attitude of the believers in Macedonia about financial giving, Paul said: “This they did, not as we hoped, but even beyond that, first they gave their own selves to the Lord, and to us, by the will of God” (2 Cor. 8:5). As Christians, each of us has been “bought with a price.” We (let alone our material possessions) don’t even belong to ourselves. When you know that you belong to the Lord, and that everything that you have belongs to the Lord, and that he is responsible to keep his promises to care for you, then you can truly be a cheerful giver.

Was this article a blessing to you? Comment below to let us know what you liked about it and what topics you'd be interested to see going forward! Also, please consider donating – even $1 helps! – to support the creation of more content like this in the future!


  1. The scriptures speak of a few different types of giving. Tithes, First Fruits, Alms and Seed. Each carries with it promises from God of blessings laid out before His children. Malachi addresses yet a people corrupt and living in sin. Tithes and offerings provide for the kingdom, there should be provision found in the House of God. We are blessed to be a blessing. Tithes show we acknowledge God as our source, it’s a form of worship and obedience. Give based on your ability to give (Mark 12:41), give to God what is right, not what is left.

  2. It is amazing that even when the truth of tithing NOT being required is proven with numerous scriptures those who deem themselves to be the authorised receivers of the tithing money on God’s behalf are incapable of hearing.

    ‘It is almost impossible to convince a man, whose livelihood depends on peoples tithes, that tithing is not required in the scriptures’

    ‘When an honestly mistaken man is shown that he is in error, he chooses to either cease to be mistaken or he ceases being honest’

  3. Just preach the word guys with grace and truth. Crticism has never changed anyone. The revealed word of God will change the hearts of men.

    1. Thanks Mark. Your comment is noted that the article has been edited to be less snarky.

    2. Thanks Mark. Your comment is note, we stand reproved, and the snakiness of the article has been removed.

    3. Thanks Mark. Your comment is noted, we stand reproved, and the article has been edited and the snakiness removed.

  4. There still happens to be 4 types of people the Proverbs have pointed out, The wise, the fool, the simple and the scoffer. Better to be a fool than a scoffer. You can show a scoffer the error of his way and yet he will continue to live in error just because he can… I was raised by a pastor. Even though I do not remember the tithe being preached so much then, when I became a Christian this is the heartbeat of the preachers all over this nation. They constantly browbeat the sheep and make them feel if they don’t do it they will get a curse place on them by God. sad. so many lost sheep fall for it.

  5. Tithes were only ever food and drink, and they were given to the Levites to feed them. Brought to Jerusalem during each of the 3 festival seasons, those who brought the tithes (food & drink) also partook of it, but of course most was left over to feed the Levites between festivals. To turn tithing from food to money, and from going to churches instead of Levites has no support in the Bible. But most churches that claim that most of the OT is done away cannot resist the idea of required giving – steady income. In 1 Corinthians 9, Paul reaffirmed tithing, pointing out that the Levites eat of the temple. But for support of the ministry he did not say to tithe money to ministers instead of food to Levites. Instead, he cited Deut 25:4 not to muzzle the ox that treads out the grain. In regard to Mal 3 about robbing God, note that most of Malachi was written to the Levites. They were to tithe of the tithe to the priests, representatives of God, and were passing on the worst looking animals and failing to give a full tithe of the tithe. For a full study of tithing and voluntary giving, visit http://www.radwritings.com and check out the 8 page PDF article “A Tithing and Giving Study.”

  6. I used to tithe, and I lied to cover when it wasn’t the “minimum” 10%. I was constantly filled with guilt, or self-righteous superiority when the hat got passed. When the spectre of sin erupted, my wife and I agreed to withhold our tithes until the rumors had passed. We never gave it, but spent it on ourselves. Then I was accused unjustly when the records indicated that I wasn’t giving. Now I give in secret, not even telling the IRS. A ministry with significant “helps & services” MUST trust God. If I give because I am so blessed when I receive, my joy impells my wallet to trust God to fill it again.

  7. Thank you for articulating this so well. A day ago this was brought to my attention. Always we have given tithe, and many regular gifts. While talking with the Lord this last week, explaining, as if He needs
    it, our need for some items, and taking care of our home. Plus some unexpected medical bills, and z cracked windshield, I was asking where is the abundance so often talked about to tithes. I had a revelation much like what you wrote.
    This is setting me free. We like to give so that is not a problem.

    I am really blessed for reading the article. I feel that is the right thing to do. Tithing or giving should not be compulsory. But it should be a free will from the heart in order to be blessed. It is rather unfortunate that some church ministers are seriously even checking members on tithing.

  9. Thanks for the clear information regarding this issue. I was very concerned about many of Christian’s who found themselves under pressure. Many started giving tithes because of the fear of the curses were preached to them using Malachi 3:10. Today you find Christians who are burdened by this,they can’t afford the Bill’s and support of their own children because of this. They end up being joyless givers which is contradictory to God’s will. This is the truth needed to liberate God’s children. The day I got this revelation, I got liberated and since then I enjoy giving. I found myself giving meaningfully than before. Be blessed.

  10. Great Article and food for thought that requires on my end greater study and research.

  11. Oh thanks for this liberating article, prior to this moment I had always been scared of the CONSEQUENCES of not Tithing.

    I was a little beat bothered about the validity of Tithing today so much, that I had to do a research about it. Fortunately I found your article, I want to say that the revealed in this article has really set me free.

    We serve God not out of fear of punishment but out of
    ‘LOVE’ because he first loved us unconditionally & unbiasedly.


Leave a Reply to Chris Smit Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.